Skip to Main Content
Nightingale Community Portal
Status Fix Live
Workspace Bugs
Created by Guest
Created on Sep 11, 2024

Trees regrown under certain structures can become Invincible

Description:
It has been observed that stumpless trees can be regrown by Carnute in spots where player had built plant boxes and plant pots - Trees regrown can become Invincible

State:
Actively being worked on

Workarounds:
- Do not build Planters over chopped down trees until this is resolved

To help the Development Team with this issue:
Nothing at this Time

Mode Both Online & Offline
Impact It's difficult to play or progress
Category Tags Resources, Farming
  • DEV RESPONSE
    Oct 3, 2024

    Hey everyone!

    Our development team has recently implemented a potential fix for tree becoming invincible.

    To confirm that this fix is in action, please check that you are running the latest version of the game, 0.5.2.300614 – visible in the top center when you log in to character creation/selection. If you are still seeing [this issue], please make a new post stating the date and start upvoting it. Upvoting is the best way to ensure visibility on issues and support us in creating a more polished game experience for you and the Nightingale community


    Additional Info:
    We have noticed that some trees that got into this state pre-patch may need a extra "push" to get them to behave. To do so use the Regrowth Spell to fully "regrow them". This should make them choppable again .

    Thank you to everyone who was able to provide us with information helping to resolve this.

  • Attach files
  • Guest
    Reply
    |
    Oct 2, 2024

    Hello I chopped the Tree's After Building over them.
    Here is what I Tried :
    - Rejoining Server*, no effect. (*Single Player)
    - Removing Foundation, Try to chop again, no effect.
    - Rejoining Server after removing foundations, no effect.

    Map was "Created" Before today's patch.

    2 replies
  • Guest
    Reply
    |
    Sep 28, 2024

    I came to this issue because I've got a couple of invulnerable trees that grew up through stone foundations. There were probably stumps there (because I build the house before I realized they could be removed), but in one case it was wholly enclosed in stone and wasn't visible. Both trees seem to be invulnerable; no damage number floats up when I try to chop them down. I've disassembled a 2x2 vertical section around one of the trees; still invulnerable.

    It seems there are two kinds of defective code here: one that make trees invulnerable under any circumstances and one that makes them grow when they shouldn't. Stumps fully encased in stone probably shouldn't grow at all.

  • Guest
    Reply
    |
    Sep 28, 2024

    Same it seems to be a range around the boxes it popped one up back in my house both trees are in the pictures


  • Guest
    Reply
    |
    Sep 27, 2024

    I am also having this issue with the trees. Basically the trees in the immediate vicinity of my house.

  • Guest
    Reply
    |
    Sep 23, 2024

    I have this problem too.

  • Guest
    Reply
    |
    Sep 20, 2024

    Here is the screenshot (sorry I didn't saw the "Attach files" button)

  • Guest
    Reply
    |
    Sep 20, 2024

    Hi, I'm having this issue too. It's pretty easy to reproduce, just cut a tree and remove his stump thinking like in any other game this will prevent tree to regrow, and this invicible tree will appear the next time you load this map. Here is the screenshot you requested: https://gyazo.com/7a3fe5d6f9860a2ce6d54ee8df1945d8


  • Guest
    Reply
    |
    Sep 19, 2024

    This totally breaks the game for me. I'll return when this is fixed.

  • Guest
    Reply
    |
    Sep 18, 2024

    I have several trees growing through my base that can't be cut down (came here from a merged post)

1 MERGED

Tree spawned in my estate and I cant get rid of it

Merged
I logged on today and found a tree in the middle of my estate. I tried chopping it down and noting. So, I deconstructed my estate all around it and still I cannot chop it down. My axe it getting worn as I chop but the tree remains invulnerable and...
4 months ago in Bugs 0 Fix Live
1 MERGED

Unchoppable trees Clipping through building

Merged
Trees that I removed the stumps of have regrown through 1 of my buildings in the Abeyance Realm, even after removing the structure intersecting the tree, the tree is unable to be chopped down again.
4 months ago in Bugs 0 Fix Live
1 MERGED

Immortal Trees appearing in areas i've clearcut including stump removal

Merged
So i have been randomly getting trees spawning or respawning in areas i've clearcut including places where i removed the stumps. These trees take no damage and appear to have no collision when I swing at them. They're growing randomly all over, in...
4 months ago in Bugs 0 Fix Live
9 MERGED

Trees growing through my house

Merged
I built a house in the Abyance realm and cut down all the trees and stumps last night. I start playing today to find that two trees are growing through my house and the axe does nothing to them.
4 months ago in Bugs 2 Fix Live
2 MERGED

Trees returning even when stump is removed, can't chop them back down.

Merged
Trees I clear out from around my base keep respawning even when I remove the stump and when they return I can't chop them back down, they are either invincible, or my axe goes straight through them as if they aren't there.
4 months ago in Bugs 0 Fix Live
1 MERGED

Plants Grows as Trees

Merged
I've cut all the trees including their stumps before building a foundation. Then I decided to create a mini garden in the middle of my base (its the planter box with marigolds and dahlias on the picture. right side). After I relog in, immortal tre...
4 months ago in Bugs 0 Fix Live
18 MERGED

Indesctructible tree inside building

Merged
Trees have regrown in the middle of my constructions and are completely indestructible. They are blocking my way, and I can't do anything anymore. Disgusted...
4 months ago in Bugs 3 Fix Live
1 MERGED

unchoppable tree clipping into my house

Merged
a tree i had chopped next to my house sprouted from the stump. maybe....or it just appeared. either way its partway in my house and even after busting out my house where it was growing through i couldnt chop it
4 months ago in Bugs 0 Fix Live
1 MERGED

trees respawned in my base and are invincible now

Merged
after i constructed my base at some point trees spawned back in in the middle of it. Can't chopp them down. Even after i demolished my base (due to building a new one) those trees can't be removed
4 months ago in Bugs 2 Fix Live
1 MERGED

Problem Following a Crash with trees reapered

Merged
After a crash, trees that I had previously cut down have reappeared despite the existing constructions. They are located next to a plant box and interact with the crops. When the plants have grown, I can harvest from the trees that have regrown us...
4 months ago in Bugs 0 Fix Live
4 MERGED

Tree stumps reappeared and can't be removed

Merged
Chopped down a tree for its wood, including its stump. But logged back in later to find that stump still there somehow. Hitting it with the axe does not result in any damage, and it now has become invincible.
4 months ago in Bugs 4 Fix Live
1 MERGED

Seemingly Invincible Tree

Merged
In my realm I have a couple trees that are either invincible and take no damage or can't be hit and the axe just goes through it like in the video provided. The trees hinder building and go through the buildings I place.
4 months ago in Bugs 1 Fix Live